February 19, 2009

Minorities Need Not Apply?

One major public education myth is that teacher certifications requirements help improve the quality of teachers. However, research by the Brookings Institution has shown that there is virtually no difference between the effectiveness of a certified teacher and an uncertified teacher.

This means that teacher certification requirements reduce the supply of effective teachers available for Nevada to hire.

Source: Brookings Institution, “Identifying Effective Teachers Using Performance on the Job

Nevada, like many states, has strong certification requirements and no real path toward alternative certification. This means that Nevada’s efforts to reduce class size have only had the result of increasing the likelihood that Nevada’s students are exposed to ineffective teachers.

Beyond harming students, teacher certification requirements also harm minorities who aspire to become teachers.

Research by Paul Peterson of the Hoover Institution found that states with real alternative teacher certification programs not only saw significant gains in student achievement but that the percentage of minority teachers increased as well. States with real, not symbolic, teacher certification pathways see a teacher population that is more reflective of state demographics.


Florida created real alternative pathways for becoming a teacher, and today about half of all new teachers in Florida are alternatively certified. The proportion of minority teachers has also increased to a level that more closely resembles the makeup of the state population.


In Nevada, however, minorities make up 41 percent of the population but less than 9 percent of our teachers. Given that 91 percent of teachers in Nevada are white, the state’s Department of Education might as well hang a sign on the door that says “minorities need not apply.”



Source: U.S. Department of Education and Hoover Institution

Nevada's legislature can remedy the situation, improving instructional quality and student achievement while also raising the number of minority teachers.

All lawmakers need to do is eliminate the state's restrictive and useless teacher certification requirements.

February 10, 2009

Teacher Pay in Nevada

According to the U.S. Census Bureau state worker pay in Nevada ranks 16th highest in the country. How well paid are Nevada's teachers?

According to the National Education Association, the nation's largest teacher union, teacher pay in Nevada ranks 22nd overall. Not bad.

But some argue that the cost of living is higher in Nevada than elsewhere, so the comparison is unfair. It is true that a straight salary comparison is an apples-to-oranges affair, but the cost-of-living adjustment is just one part of the equation.

The John Locke Foundation recently released national rankings of teacher pay that were not only adjusted for costs of living, but included teacher pensions and teacher experience as well. This is important to include because teachers are paid extra based on the number of years they've worked and not how well they actually teach students. States with younger teachers will see a lower average pay than states with older teachers.

The John Locke Foundation found that when making an apples-to-apples comparison, Nevada's teacher pay turns out to be 17th best in the country.

Rank
State
Adjusted Compensation

1
Georgia
$72,393

2
Illinois
$70,238

3
Kentucky
$66,270

4
Alabama
$65,723

5
Arkansas
$64,907

6
Delaware
$64,523

7
Ohio
$63,683

8
Michigan
$63,572

9
Alaska
$63,125

10
Texas
$62,663

11
Rhode Island
$62,146

12
Arizona
$60,120

13
New York
$59,972

14
North Carolina
$59,252

15
Missouri
$58,574

16
California
$58,452

17
Nevada
$57,983

18
New Mexico
$57,800

19
Louisiana
$57,633

20
Oregon
$56,789

21
Colorado
$56,529

22
Indiana
$56,412

23
Maryland
$56,059

24
Oklahoma
$55,792

25
Pennsylvania
$55,438

26
Virginia
$55,337

27
Idaho
$55,179

28
Utah
$55,112

29
Mississippi
$55,103

30
Connecticut
$55,021

31
Massachusetts
$54,812

32
Wisconsin
$54,740

33
Tennessee
$53,985

34
Florida
$53,238

35
Wyoming
$52,304

36
Washington
$52,277

37
South Carolina
$51,510

38
Minnesota
$51,437

39
Kansas
$51,191

40
Nebraska
$50,036

41
New Jersey
$49,866

42
Iowa
$46,585

43
D.C.
$45,474

44
Hawaii
$43,804

45
West Virginia
$42,858

46
New Hampshire
$42,089

47
Montana
$40,800

48
North Dakota
$39,981

49
South Dakota
$39,835

50
Vermont
$39,674

Median
$55,387


Source: http://www.johnlocke.org/acrobat/spotlights/spotlight-367_teacherpay2009.pdf